
EAC, poza narzędziami z pakietu PlexTools [obsługującymi tylko i wyłącznie nagrywarki firmy Plextor] praktycznie nie ma konkurencji na rynku profesjonalnych ripperów audio. Programy takie jak AudioGrabber, Windows Media Player, CDEX, Easy CDDA Extractor pomimo szumnych reklam, wielkich haseł i często sporej ceny tak naprawdę niewiele potrafią. Żaden inny program, poza EAC i PlexTools nie potrafi wyłączyć buforowania napędu, co w przypadku porysowanych płyt dramatycznie przekłada się na jakość wykonanych kopii. Więc jeśli ktokolwiek chce uzyskać NAPRAWDĘ dobrej jakości kopię płyty audio, powinien sięgnąć po Exact Audio Copy. Na naszych łamach ukazały się
trzy świetne artykuły dotyczące wykorzystania tego bardzo dobrego programu.
Korzystając z programu ExactAudioCopy odczytaliśmy zestaw płyt testowych w celu określenia wydajności testowanego sprzętu przy odczycie nośników z nagraniami audio. Zestaw płyt obejmuje:
- Tłoczoną płytę audio
-
Kopię w/w płyty audio na nośniku CD-R
W czasie konfiguracji programu odczytywane są jego atrybuty:
EAC oferuje dwa tryby odczytu, różniące się jakością materiału wynikowego. Zgodnie z logiką, im niższa jakość tym krótszy czas odczytu całej płyty.
| Tryb burst: |
| Płyta tłoczona |
Kopia |
| Philips SPD6003BD | 00:02:16 | | | LiteON LH-20A1P | 00:02:17 | | | AOpen DUW1616L | 00:02:18 | | | HP dvd1035i | 00:02:18 | | | LiteON SHM-165S6S | 00:02:20 | | | BenQ DW1650 | 00:02:24 | | | TEAC DV-W524GS | 00:02:29 | | | Samsung SH-S223F | 00:02:36 | | | Samsung SH-S222L | 00:02:36 | | | OptiArc AD-7173S | 00:02:38 | | | LG GSA-H44N | 00:02:38 | | | Samsung SH-S203B | 00:02:38 | | | LG GSA-H12N | 00:02:38 | | | LG GSA-E10N | 00:02:39 | | | NEC ND-4550A | 00:02:40 | | | LG GSA-H42N | 00:02:40 | | | LG GSA-H10N | 00:02:40 | | | NEC ND-4571A | 00:02:41 | | | OptiArc AD-7173A | 00:02:41 | | | LG GSA-E40N | 00:02:41 | | | Pioneer DVR-112 | 00:02:41 | | | LG GH20LS10 | 00:02:41 | | | LG GSA-4167B | 00:02:42 | | | LG GSA-H20L | 00:02:43 | | | Samsung SH-W163A | 00:02:43 | | | Samsung SH-S182D | 00:02:44 | | | Samsung SH-S183L | 00:02:44 | | | LG GSA-4166B | 00:02:44 | | | Pioneer DVR-215 | 00:02:45 | | | Pioneer DVR-S18L | 00:02:48 | | | Sony DW-G120A | 00:02:50 | | | Asus DRW-1612BL | 00:02:51 | | | ASUS DRW-1814BLT | 00:02:54 | | | Pioneer DVR-110DBK | 00:02:55 | | | HIVISION DRW-3S163 | 00:02:57 | | | Pioneer DVR-212 | 00:03:10 | | | Pioneer DVR-111DBK | 00:03:57 | | | Samsung SE-S204S | 00:04:21 | | | LG GSA-H55L | 00:04:32 | | | Pioneer DVR-109 | 00:05:38 | | | Pioneer DVR-115 | 00:06:09 | | | LiteON LH-18A1P | 00:06:36 | | | Samsung SH-S162L | 00:06:41 | | | Samsung SH-W162C | 00:06:44 | | | Sony DRU-810A | 00:08:55 | | | Philips DVDR1668P1 | 00:08:58 | | | Philips DVDR1648P1 | 00:08:58 | | | Philips DVDR1660P1 | 00:08:58 | | | BenQ DW1640 | 00:09:00 | | | Plextor PX-800A | 00:09:04 | | | BenQ DW1670 | 00:09:25 | | | Plextor PX-755A | 00:09:38 | | | Plextor PX-760A | 00:09:39 | | | Plextor PX-716A | 00:09:39 | | | Sony DW-G121A | 00:09:40 | | | LiteON SHW-16H5S | 00:09:40 | | | Plextor PX-750A | 00:10:01 | | | Plextor PX-608CU | 00:10:55 | | | Pioneer DVR-116 | 00:12:09 | | | Philips DVDR16LS | 00:20:34 | | | LiteON SOHW-1693S | 00:20:57 | | | HP 640c | 00:36:58 | |
|
|
| Samsung SH-W162C | 00:02:04 | | | AOpen DUW1616L | 00:02:17 | | | Philips SPD6003BD | 00:02:17 | | | Philips DVDR1668P1 | 00:02:18 | | | BenQ DW1640 | 00:02:18 | | | LiteON LH-20A1P | 00:02:18 | | | Philips DVDR1648P1 | 00:02:19 | | | LiteON LH-18A1P | 00:02:19 | | | BenQ DW1650 | 00:02:20 | | | LiteON SHW-16H5S | 00:02:21 | | | HP dvd1035i | 00:02:21 | | | Philips DVDR1660P1 | 00:02:22 | | | OptiArc AD-7173S | 00:02:37 | | | LG GH20LS10 | 00:02:39 | | | Sony DW-G121A | 00:02:40 | | | LG GSA-E40N | 00:02:40 | | | ASUS DRW-1814BLT | 00:02:40 | | | Plextor PX-800A | 00:02:41 | | | LG GSA-H20L | 00:02:41 | | | OptiArc AD-7173A | 00:02:42 | | | Samsung SH-S182D | 00:02:42 | | | LG GSA-H10N | 00:02:42 | | | Samsung SH-S183L | 00:02:42 | | | Sony DRU-810A | 00:02:42 | | | NEC ND-4550A | 00:02:42 | | | HIVISION DRW-3S163 | 00:02:42 | | | Samsung SH-S162L | 00:02:43 | | | LG GSA-4167B | 00:02:43 | | | Pioneer DVR-110DBK | 00:02:44 | | | LG GSA-E10N | 00:02:44 | | | LG GSA-H44N | 00:02:44 | | | LG GSA-H12N | 00:02:44 | | | LG GSA-H42N | 00:02:45 | | | Samsung SH-W163A | 00:02:45 | | | Samsung SH-S223F | 00:02:45 | | | Asus DRW-1612BL | 00:02:47 | | | Samsung SH-S203B | 00:02:48 | | | Samsung SH-S222L | 00:02:49 | | | Pioneer DVR-111DBK | 00:02:49 | | | LG GSA-4166B | 00:02:51 | | | Pioneer DVR-212 | 00:02:52 | | | Pioneer DVR-112 | 00:02:52 | | | Philips DVDR16LS | 00:02:53 | | | NEC ND-4571A | 00:04:18 | | | LG GSA-H55L | 00:04:30 | | | Pioneer DVR-116 | 00:04:34 | | | Samsung SE-S204S | 00:04:40 | | | Pioneer DVR-115 | 00:04:43 | | | Pioneer DVR-215 | 00:04:58 | | | Plextor PX-608CU | 00:05:54 | | | TEAC DV-W524GS | 00:06:22 | | | LiteON SHM-165S6S | 00:06:26 | | | Plextor PX-750A | 00:08:34 | | | BenQ DW1670 | 00:08:58 | | | Plextor PX-716A | 00:09:38 | | | Plextor PX-755A | 00:09:38 | | | Plextor PX-760A | 00:09:38 | | | Sony DW-G120A | 00:09:39 | | | Pioneer DVR-S18L | 00:10:55 | | | Pioneer DVR-109 | 00:11:28 | | | LiteON SOHW-1693S | 00:21:17 | | | HP 640c | 00:35:31 | |
|
|
| Tryb secure: |
| Płyta tłoczona |
Kopia |
| LG GSA-H12N | 00:02:55 | | | LG GSA-E40N | 00:02:56 | | | LG GSA-4167B | 00:02:56 | | | LG GSA-H10N | 00:02:57 | | | LG GSA-E10N | 00:02:58 | | | LG GH20LS10 | 00:02:58 | | | TEAC DV-W524GS | 00:03:04 | | | Plextor PX-800A | 00:03:05 | | | LG GSA-H44N | 00:03:18 | | | Samsung SH-S222L | 00:03:25 | | | LG GSA-H42N | 00:03:26 | | | ASUS DRW-1814BLT | 00:03:28 | | | Samsung SH-S223F | 00:03:32 | | | Samsung SH-S203B | 00:03:33 | | | Asus DRW-1612BL | 00:03:41 | | | OptiArc AD-7173S | 00:03:48 | | | NEC ND-4571A | 00:03:56 | | | NEC ND-4550A | 00:03:58 | | | OptiArc AD-7173A | 00:03:59 | | | Samsung SE-S204S | 00:05:19 | | | HP dvd1035i | 00:07:18 | | | LiteON SHM-165S6S | 00:07:25 | | | Samsung SH-S162L | 00:07:26 | | | Samsung SH-S183L | 00:07:32 | | | Samsung SH-S182D | 00:08:01 | | | Samsung SH-W162C | 00:08:11 | | | Samsung SH-W163A | 00:08:24 | | | Pioneer DVR-116 | 00:09:57 | | | Pioneer DVR-215 | 00:10:07 | | | AOpen DUW1616L | 00:10:09 | | | Plextor PX-750A | 00:11:04 | | | BenQ DW1670 | 00:11:05 | | | Pioneer DVR-212 | 00:11:15 | | | Pioneer DVR-112 | 00:11:22 | | | Pioneer DVR-110DBK | 00:12:11 | | | Pioneer DVR-S18L | 00:12:14 | | | Pioneer DVR-115 | 00:16:08 | | | LG GSA-H20L | 00:16:15 | | | LG GSA-H55L | 00:16:20 | | | LG GSA-4166B | 00:16:59 | | | Philips SPD6003BD | 00:18:45 | | | LiteON LH-20A1P | 00:18:47 | | | LiteON LH-18A1P | 00:19:46 | | | HP 640c | 00:20:23 | | | Philips DVDR16LS | 00:21:00 | | | Pioneer DVR-109 | 00:23:53 | | | HIVISION DRW-3S163 | 00:29:21 | | | Sony DW-G121A | 00:29:31 | | | LiteON SHW-16H5S | 00:29:37 | | | Sony DW-G120A | 00:29:47 | | | Pioneer DVR-111DBK | 00:30:27 | | | Plextor PX-755A | 00:30:48 | | | Plextor PX-760A | 00:30:55 | | | Plextor PX-716A | 00:31:40 | | | Plextor PX-608CU | 00:32:53 | | | Philips DVDR1668P1 | 00:34:51 | | | BenQ DW1650 | 00:34:53 | | | Sony DRU-810A | 00:34:53 | | | Philips DVDR1660P1 | 00:35:04 | | | BenQ DW1640 | 00:35:05 | | | LiteON SOHW-1693S | 00:35:43 | | | Philips DVDR1648P1 | 00:35:44 | |
|
|
| LG GSA-H12N | 00:02:53 | | | LG GSA-E40N | 00:02:54 | | | LG GSA-H44N | 00:02:54 | | | LG GSA-E10N | 00:02:58 | | | LG GH20LS10 | 00:02:58 | | | LG GSA-H42N | 00:02:59 | | | LG GSA-4167B | 00:03:03 | | | LG GSA-H10N | 00:03:05 | | | ASUS DRW-1814BLT | 00:03:29 | | | Samsung SH-S203B | 00:03:33 | | | Samsung SH-S223F | 00:03:42 | | | NEC ND-4550A | 00:03:52 | | | Asus DRW-1612BL | 00:03:59 | | | NEC ND-4571A | 00:04:03 | | | OptiArc AD-7173S | 00:04:06 | | | OptiArc AD-7173A | 00:04:36 | | | Samsung SE-S204S | 00:05:26 | | | Plextor PX-800A | 00:06:33 | | | Samsung SH-S183L | 00:07:39 | | | TEAC DV-W524GS | 00:07:40 | | | LiteON LH-18A1P | 00:07:46 | | | Samsung SH-S222L | 00:07:53 | | | Samsung SH-S162L | 00:08:03 | | | Samsung SH-S182D | 00:08:07 | | | Samsung SH-W162C | 00:08:13 | | | Samsung SH-W163A | 00:08:18 | | | Pioneer DVR-116 | 00:08:41 | | | Philips DVDR1668P1 | 00:09:40 | | | BenQ DW1650 | 00:09:51 | | | BenQ DW1640 | 00:09:52 | | | Philips DVDR1660P1 | 00:09:56 | | | BenQ DW1670 | 00:10:00 | | | AOpen DUW1616L | 00:10:12 | | | Philips DVDR1648P1 | 00:10:12 | | | Plextor PX-750A | 00:10:13 | | | Pioneer DVR-215 | 00:10:33 | | | Sony DRU-810A | 00:11:09 | | | Pioneer DVR-212 | 00:11:44 | | | Pioneer DVR-112 | 00:11:59 | | | Pioneer DVR-110DBK | 00:12:00 | | | Pioneer DVR-S18L | 00:12:21 | | | Pioneer DVR-111DBK | 00:12:29 | | | Pioneer DVR-115 | 00:13:50 | | | Philips DVDR16LS | 00:14:01 | | | LG GSA-H55L | 00:15:08 | | | LG GSA-H20L | 00:16:23 | | | LG GSA-4166B | 00:16:55 | | | LiteON LH-20A1P | 00:19:02 | | | Philips SPD6003BD | 00:19:04 | | | HP dvd1035i | 00:19:07 | | | LiteON SHM-165S6S | 00:19:10 | | | HP 640c | 00:20:30 | | | Plextor PX-608CU | 00:20:40 | | | Sony DW-G121A | 00:29:31 | | | LiteON SHW-16H5S | 00:29:39 | | | Sony DW-G120A | 00:29:39 | | | Plextor PX-760A | 00:30:49 | | | Plextor PX-755A | 00:30:49 | | | HIVISION DRW-3S163 | 00:30:56 | | | Plextor PX-716A | 00:31:24 | | | LiteON SOHW-1693S | 00:35:25 | | | Pioneer DVR-109 | 00:40:48 | |
|
|

Zabezpieczenia płyt Audio to niestety w dzisiejszych czasach standard. Warto więc zadbać o to by wybrany napęd pozwalał na odczyt i wykonanie kopii bezpieczeństwa nagrań które wybierzemy. Nie będziemy dokładnie opisywać czym charakteryzują się poszczególne zabezpieczenia, gdyż o tym możecie przeczytać m.in. na naszym Forum. Poniżej prezentujemy tabelę z wynikami:
|
Celin Dion A New Day Has Come Key2Audio |
Massive Attack 100th Window CDS200.0.4- 3.0 build 12b |
Leszczek Moder Nienasycenie CDS200.5.0.151 5.00.160 |
| AOpen DUW1616L | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Asus DRW-1612BL |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| BenQ DW1640 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| BenQ DW1650 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| BenQ DW1670 |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| HiVISION DRW-3S163 | Tak | Nie | Nie |
| LG GSA-4166B | Nie | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-4167B | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-E10N | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-H10N | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-H20L | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-H42N | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LiteON SHW-16H5S | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LiteON SOHW-1693S | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LiteON LH-18A1P |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| LiteON SHM-165S6S |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| NEC ND-4550A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| NEC ND-4571A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| OptiArc AD-7173A |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Philips DVDR16LS | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Philips DVDR1648P1 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Philips DVDR1660P1 |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-110DBK | Nie | Tak | Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-111DBK |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Plextor PX-750A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Plextor PX-755A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Plextor PX-760A |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Plextor PX-716A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Samsung SH-W162C | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Samsung SH-S162L |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Samsung SH-S182D |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Samsung SH-W163A |
Tak |
Tak |
Tak |
| Sony DW-G120A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LiteON LH-20A1P | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Philips SPD6003BD | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-H12N | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-112 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-E40N | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| OptiArc AD-7173S | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| ASUS DRW-1814BLT | Nie | Tak | Tak |
| Plextor PX-608CU | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Plextor PX-800A | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-H55L | Nie | Tak | Tak |
| LG GSA-H44N | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Samsung SH-S203B | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| HP dvd1035i | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-212 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| LG GH20LS10 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-115 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-215 | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Samsung SE-S204S | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Samsung SSH-S223F | Tak | Tak | Tak |
| Pioneer DVR-116 | Tak | Tak | Tak |